Peanut Butter Banana Frozen Yogurt Pops with Chocolate Drizzle
You guys know what’s really weird?
I absolutely HATE being cold, but yet I continue to make frozen treats.
Frozen treats that when I photograph, make me shiver. For some reason every time I shoot any kind of ice cream my hands end up molding the ice cream into a cone, or sandwiching it between cookies, or even stuffing it into tacos. It’s like I have never heard of utensils. I mean, sure I have them…….but I never use them. Which is why at the end of the day I am always covered in ice cream, chocolate, cheese, avocados and my very favorite, fruit. Pretty sure I had a nice lick of watermelon on my face yesterday or maybe it was strawberry, actually I bet it was a mix.
It was good.
What, you guys don’t lick dried up fruit off your face for a little afternoon pick me up?
Oh no, that’s just me. It’s ok, I am cool with that.
Anywhoo, I decided to do something smart. Well actually I did something smart and then I followed it up with something pretty stupid. Let’s start with the smart first, so hopefully the stupid thing won’t look so well, stupid. See I had this idea, I wanted to make frozen yogurt, but then I was like “oh, I should totally make them into cute little pops.” Then I decided they needed to be peanut butter and then I was like well if I am doing peanut butter I might as well throw in a banana, because peanut butter and banana pretty much just rules.
Normally when I get an idea I either write it down or make it right then and there if I happen to have all the ingredients. Well, I hade everything I needed for the pops – greek yogurt, bananas, honey, vanilla, those are all staples around here, I always have them. So, I decided to do a little kitchen experiment. Sometimes these “experiments” work and sometime I end up with a pile of not so pretty food and a huge mess. Either way though I end up with a huge mess. It is inevitable with me.
So I threw everything in the food processor, processed away and wa-la it worked! Dang good, crazy easy, actually healthy, frozen yogurt. Miracle! Really, all I needed was a spoon, ehh my finger did the job pretty well though actually.
Then I stuck it in the freezer to firm up so I could easily spoon the yogurt into circles since I am not cool and do not own a popsicle mold. Now, here comes the stupid part. I spooned all the yogurt onto a baking pan and then I realized ah, I actually needed popsicle sticks.
Duh. I mean pops normally means something on a stick.
But wait, then I got smart again and decided to use my very favorite Target straws that I picked up at Easter time. Ah, now that’s what’s ups. Quick on the spot thinking! Brilliant, right?
Yeah, right. The only problem is, now I have no more cute straws, and trust me Target does not have them anymore. I looked and asked like a very obnoxious straw loving freak. Pretty sure the guy working at Target thought I was a loony. Pretty sure he’s right.
Ok, so like I said these are so easy and you only need a food processor or a blender and maybe some popsicle sticks, straws or any other stick like object. Oh, wait and did I tell you about the chocolate drizzle? You gotta have a little chocolate with your peanut butter. Plus, drizzling chocolate is so fun. Really it is, just try it.


Nutritional information is only an estimate. The accuracy of the nutritional information for any recipe on this site is not guaranteed.
Peanut Butter Banana Frozen Yogurt Pops with Chocolate Drizzle
By halfbakedharvest
Course: Dessert, Snack
Cuisine: American
Keyword: chocolate, frozen yoghurt
These are so easy and you only need a food processor or a blender and maybe some popsicle sticks, straws or any other stick like object. Oh, wait and did I tell you about the chocolate drizzle? You gotta have a little chocolate with your peanut butter. Plus, drizzling chocolate is so fun. Really it is, just try it.
Ingredients
- 2 bananas preferably frozen (they can be at room temp too)
- 1 1/2 cups greek yogurt I used 0%
- 2/3 cup peanut butter
- 4 tablespoons honey
- 2 teaspoons vanilla
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
Chocolate Shell
- 12 ounces mik chocolate chopped
- 1/3 cup coconut oil
- chopped peanuts for topping optional
Instructions
-
Place the bananas in the bowl of a food processor or high powered blender and process until smooth and pureed. Add in the greek yogurt, peanut butter, honey, vanilla and salt and process another minute or so. Make sure there are no chunks of yogurt or banana and everything is thoroughly combined. Transfer the frozen yogurt to a bowl, cover and place in the freezer for 30 minutes to firm up or if your bananas were frozen in the beginning you can skip this step. You need the yogurt to stiffen and be cold so it will hold its shape on its own, if it seems too thin place it back in in the freezer for another 30 minutes.
-
Line two baking sheets with a silpat or wax paper and spoon the frozen yogurt onto the baking sheet, making small circles. Place a popsicle stick or straw in the middle of each circle and then cover with more frozen yogurt if needed to cover the stick. Cover the baking pans and place in the freezer for for at least 2 hours.
-
Before you take the frozen yogurt out of the freezer make the magic shell. Combine chopped chocolate and coconut oil in a medium sauce pan over medium heat. Stir frequently until chocolate is almost melted. Remove from heat and stir until completely melted and smooth.
-
Remove the frozen yogurt pops from the freezer and drizzle the magic shell over the pops. Immediately sprinkle (seriously, do it pretty fast) with the chopped peanut and let harden, about 2 minutes. Either eat right away or store in the freezer to grab when ya need one!
Recipe Notes
You may also just use a cupcake tin or popsicle mold instead of forming the frozen yogurt into pops. If you use any kind of mold you do not have to freeze the yogurt for 30 minutes before hand. Just pour into your molds and freeze 2 hours as directed.

Trust me, you NEED these today. They help you get through the “Oh man the long weekend’s over and it’s back to the grind”.
Yes, yes, and YES!! I need a few of these to cool me off!
Hehe! Thanks Steph! Is really hot were you live already?
YES!! We’re in the 90’s already :/ and a serious drought! Blah
These are so cute!!
I hate being cold too…but can’t resist treats like these!
Thank you Kristen.
Oh and being cold stinks!
These look so good! I’ll make them and sub sun butter for the peanut butter (I’m allergic to nuts).
Thanks Nessa and greta idea to use the sun butter!
These are absolutely adorable and I love that they’re made with Greek yogurt! What a great idea to whiz up the yogurt with a frozen banana to make the frozen yogurt.
Thank you so much Dara!! They are so good and So easy! I love that pretty much anyone can make them! All you need is a blender or food processor!
What a neat idea! This is great for summer.
Thank you, Leah!
These look fabulous! Good job! 🙂
Thanks so much Liam!
The peanut butter fans in my house will love these!
Yay! Thanks Eva!
I’m so warm-natured that I can’t help but crave cold stuff year-round! I always have the biggest ice cream cravings in the middle of the winter! 🙂
hehe! I am always cold, but I would probably never turn down a cold treat in the winter. They are to good to pass up!
Eeep! I love these little sticks of frozen heaven. Totally going on my to-try list.
Thank you Ashley! Hope you love them!
What beautiful presentation! I can’t even imagine how good they taste too!
Oh these make me so blissfully happy Tiegs! I love cold things when it’s cold out. I’m a weirdo like that.
Ha! I love that you call me Tiegs! Seriously, I think that is oddly awesome and I have no idea why!
Thanks Megan!
These are genius! Good for you, improvising on the spot! 🙂 Is greek yogurt the preferred yogurt of choice for frozen yogurt?
I just love greek yogurt and it is a lot thicker than the regular stuff, but I do think you could use regular yogurt if you wanted.
Thank you, Mimi!
healthy… and chocolate… and peanut butter… i don’t think there’s anything better!
I know, right?
Thanks Faith!
I think we need to live next door to each other and just eat ice cream for a living. Right?
Totally agree!
LURVE these! They’re so cute! 🙂 Also anything that resembles ice cream is a winner in my book.
Thank you so much Stephanie!
I love it when something just works out!
Trust me, me too!
Thanks Carrian!
Love the PB fro-yo idea! You are the queen of chilled/frozen desserts. And very brave for wanting to photograph melty stuff. As discussed, things tend to melt on my WAY before I am ready for that 🙂 I’d love one of these babies now!
Thank you, Averie! The queen of frozen desserts? I think like that!
Oh my goodness those look incredible! Thanks for sharing 🙂
Happy Blogging!
Happy Valley Chow
Thank you!
If these are made with Greek yogurt, that means they’re healthy, which means a serving size is 18, right?
Totally!
Ok talk about amazing! I love the PB frozen yogurt!! You have the best frozen dessert recipes on here, Tieghan. And your photography is incredible. I never, ever have luck with frozen things. They always melt too quickly! Chocolate, PB, + banana = amazing my friend. Just splendid. 😉
Wow! Sally, thank you! Your comment is too nice! It truly means the world to me and especially from you! Thank you!
I’m pretty sure these are heaven on a stick!! 😉 YUM!!
Thank you, Jocelyn!
This looks delicious. I haven’t tried making my own frozen yogurt yet but it looks pretty easy. Plus I could let my preschool drizzle the chocolate on it. He loves doing that.
It really is so easy and drizzling the chocolate is exactly what my little sister did, she loves that too! Hope you guys give these a try and love them!
These look amazing!
Thank you, Jeni!
These look great! I wanted to let you know that will be featuring these tomorrow in my “What I Bookmarked This Week” post – stop by and see!
Thank you Danielle and thanks for the feature!!
Wow! This sounds fantastic!
Thank you!
Thanks for joining me at Two Cup Tuesday! I hope to see you again Monday night at Pint Sized Baker.
Thank you!
These pops sound soo good! My husband would love these with the peanuts and chocolate…yum!
Thank you, Lyuba!!
LOVE these Tieghan! Just got back from the store and it is 101 outside – sooo could use one of these right now 🙂
Whoa! 101! That is hot! Hope you get something to cool off with!
Thanks Trish!
These look delicious!! Yum!!
Thank you, Diane!
These look delicious. Two of my favorite ingredients, peanut butter and banana.
Debi
Thank you, Debi! PB and banana is my favorite too!
You are featured this week on Busy Monday at A Pinch of Joy! I hope you will stop by and grab a Featured Button from the Button Box on the sidebar. Pinned.
Thank you so much, Charlene!! Hope you had a great weekend!
So excited about the healthful ingredients in these gorgeous pops!! Love.
Thank you, Kelly! I love that you are excited!
Hi Tieghan, Your recipe is amazing. The snaps are awesome. Pleasure to find your blog post and to know about this delicious recipe. And at last would like to say Thank you for sharing it with us.
Thanks so much, Josie! So happy you loved these!
Yum! These were fun to make and easy. Made with out stick . Frozen yogurt cup. 😃
Love that!! Thank you for trying this one, Genevieve! xTieghan