Death By Butterbeer Cupcakes w/Treacle Butter Frosting + Chocolate Covered Pretzels.
I have been waiting so long to make a butterbeer cupcake.
Like too many years.
I do not know if you know this, but I am huge Harry Potter fan. I know, I know, who the heck isn’t. I am not one of those die-hards or anything, but I have to say, the Harry Potter books are about the only books I have ever read page for page and truly enjoyed. It’s just my era I guess, but I will always love Harry Potter. The series brings back awesome memories for me.
I will forever love the Harry Potter marathon weekends on ABC family. They will never get old. Never.
Ok, and I just have to throw this in there too, ABC Family’s 25 Days of Christmas? Yeah, that is something I look forward to all year-long. Like no joke, that is my favorite thing. Call me whatever you want but, I will always be a 25 Days of Christmas Girl… and don’t judge, you know you are too.
Come every October though, it seems I have Harry Potter on the brain. I mean, it makes sense since October is all about magical, spooky things. Normally, I just watch the movies over and over until I can move on to the Christmas movies, but this year that just was not enough.
I was out hiking the other day and I thought back to these broom stick cookies I made. They were one of my very first posts on this blog and the photos are horrific, but the cookies are cute, and so good. I was thinking about how cute they would be with a butterbeer cupcake and that was it, that was when the decision was made. I was making butterbeer cupcakes… death by butterbeer cupcakes.
Hey, it’s October. Death By Butterbeer just seemed fitting.
If you are wondering, butterbeer (or at least the butterbeer in this recipe), is basically just butterscotch mixed with a little butter extract. It’s beyond delicious you guys. Super sweet, crazy “fall” like, and I am not going to lie – so addicting. Literally, the butterbeer glaze could be a dessert in itself? I am thinking small espresso mug filled with warm butterbeer glaze, drizzle of chocolate and marshmallows. OH MY GOSH. That would be good. Gotta do that sometime.
Cupcakes today though.
The cupcake itself is really simple. It’s made with brown sugar and butter extract, but I also added in some vanilla bean and um, chocolate covered toffee bits because they just needed to happen. I have had a bag of bits sitting in my pantry since last fall and these cupcakes just called out to them. They’re a match made in the cupcake heavens. The vanilla beans just add such great flavor. You can never go wrong with vanilla beans. Honestly you just can’t. They work with just about everything and they make recipes that much more special.
For the frosting, I had to go chocolate…and chocolate treacle butter!! It may just be physically impossible for me to have an all non-chocolate dessert. PLUS butterbeer and chocolate together seemed like such a good pairing. Topped off with some chocolate covered pretzels? Yeah, why not? It is finally that time of year again, when chocolate, sugar salt, carbs and all the good stuff is totally acceptable – every single freaking day. Or at least in my head it is.
Good months ahead…
Really though, this frosting is oh my gosh, GOOD. It’s the whole treacle butter thing which is really just unsulphured molasses and salted butter. It may seem simple, but when combined with a little butterbeer and a little chocolate? Um just, yes!
Finally, I do realize that these photos sort of look like a craft project gone wrong AND most importantly that the scarf is scarlet and white, not scarlet and yellow. I tried so hard to find a scarlet and yellow scarf, but had no luck. I found one online, but I really did not want to wait for it to get it here. So… sorry for the scarlet and white. I tried, really I tried.
And the as for the photos themselves, I was SO close to not even showing you these because they are not “my kind of perfect”, but my mom talked me into keeping them. Sorry for my craft project gone wrong, but I promise the cupcakes themselves are delish.
Double finally, if you have kids these are the cupcakes that will make you the “cool” mom or dad – guaranteed. If I could, I would bring them into Asher’s school on Halloween, but they have this new rule of no sweets for birthdays and holidays. I get it, but at the same time, it’s so lame. For me, in school class parties filled with the homemade treats where the best. ESPECIALLY on Halloween.
Halloween is meant for an all day sugar high.
Nutritional information is only an estimate. The accuracy of the nutritional information for any recipe on this site is not guaranteed.
Death By Butterbeer Cupcakes w/Treacle Butter Frosting + Chocolate Covered Pretzels.
By halfbakedharvest
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: American
Keyword: cupcakes
These butterscotch and butter cupcakes are pure magic...and delicious
Ingredients
Cupcakes
- 2 cups all-purpose flour
- 1 teaspoon baking powder
- 1 teaspoon baking soda
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
- 1 cup brown sugar
- 3 large eggs
- 1/2 cup canola oil
- 1 teaspoon butter extract
- Seeds from one vanilla bean divided
- 1/2 cup buttermilk
- 1/2 cup pumpkin beer * or cream soda
- 1 cup toffee bits optional
Butterbeer Sauce
- 1 (11 ounce) bag butterscotch chips
- 1/2 cup heavy cream
- 1 tablespoon honey
Treacle Butter Frosting + Chocolate Pretzels
- 30-40 mini pretzel twists
- 9 ounces semi-sweet or milk chocolate melted
- 8 tablespoons salted butter softened
- 2 teaspoons unsulphured molasses
- 1 3/4 cup powdered sugar or more if desired
- 3 tablespoons unsweetened cocoa powder
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1 teaspoon butter extract
- 1/3 cup butterbeer sauce directions above
- 2 tablespoons heavy whipping cream
- [broom stick cookies | https://dev.halfbakedharvest.com/witches-broom-sticks/] for decorating (optional)
Instructions
-
Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Line 2 standard cupcake pans with 18 liners.
-
In a medium size mixing bowl, combine the flour, baking powder, baking soda, salt and brown sugar.
-
In the bowl of a stand mixer or in a large mixing bowl, combine the eggs, canola oil, butter extract, seeds from half a vanilla bean and the buttermilk. Beat until smooth.
-
Slowly add the dry ingredients to the wet ingredients with the mixer on low until there are no longer any clumps of flour. Add the beer and mix until combined. Batter should be pourable, but not super thin. Stir in the toffee bits - if using.
-
Fill baking cups three-fourths full. Bake for about 18-22 minutes. Allow to cool completely before frosting.
-
Meanwhile, make the butterbeer sauce. Add the butterscotch chips, cream and honey to a small sauce pot. Set over low heat, stirring often until melted and smooth. Remove from the heat.
-
To make the frosting, melt chocolate in the microwave on 30 second intervals, stirring between each, until smooth. You may also use a double broiler. Dip each pretzel in chocolate, allowing excess to drip off. Place on wax paper lined cookie sheets and chill in the freezer until firm, about 10 minutes.
-
Add the butter, molasses and powdered sugar to the bowl of a stand mixer (or use a hand held mixer). Beat the butter and powdered sugar together until the butter is light and fluffy, about 4 minutes. Add the cocoa powder, vanilla and butter extract. Beat, scrapping down the sides as needed another 2 minutes or until there are no streaks of white. Beat in 1/3 cup butterbeer sauce + the seeds from 1/2 of the remaining vanilla bean until smooth and creamy. Add 2 tablespoons of the heavy cream and whip the frosting for 2-4 minutes or until light and fluffy. Taste the frosting and add more powdered sugar if you like a sweeter or thicker frosting.
-
Now take about 1/3 to 1/2 the chocolate covered pretzels and finely chop them. Stir the pretzels into the frosting. Skip this step if you like a smooth frosting.
-
To assemble the cupcakes, pipe frosting onto each cupcakes (or just smooth it on with a knife). Garnish each cupcake with a chocolate covered pretzel. If needed, warm the butterbeer sauce until just smooth enough to drizzle. Drizzle each cupcake with butterbeer sauce just before serving. Sink your teeth in!
That’s what butterbeer dreams look like. It’s the glaze and the pretzels and the treacle b butter frosting and most definitely the cupcake. Really it’s the whole darn thing!
….(my jaw just dropped to the floor) These cupcakes do HP justice, indeed!
Thank you! Have a great weekend!
I am soooo with you on the Harry Potter obsession. I’ve made butterbeer a few times, but need to get on these cupcakes. Like, now.
YA! Gotta love Harry Potter!! Thanks Katrina! I have to try butterbeer next! 🙂
Oh my gosh. My inner fat kid and inner Hufflepuff are having a party right now! These look so delicious. Now, I’m off to watch the HP marathon again because you’ve put me in the mood!
Haha!! Thank you!!
PS watching Harry Potter as I type. LOL!
How glad am I to see I’m not the only one obsessed with good old Harry! Love those cupcakes – it’s perfect weather for butterbeer anything!
Thanks Nora! Have a great weekend!
You don’t like these photos? I’m glad you shared them anyway because I still wanted to lick the screen. These are the prettiest, coolest, most delicious looking fun cupcakes LOVE!
Thank you, Bri!
These are impressive! I am currently at the end of book seven in the series, and have loved every word of them. I am really dying to make that butterbeer sauce to drizzle on everything!
OH how fun!! I kind of wish I was in your shoes right now. The end is intense! ENJOOY! 🙂
these look insane!! my niece and nephew would go crazy for these 🙂
Thank you!! Kids LOVE them! 🙂
Hello gorgeous! Those photos. Those flavors. Dying over the HP tie in. Genius!
Thank you, Meg!! Have a great weekend!
I love Harry Potter, but I especially love ABC’s 25 Days of Christmas (along with Fa-La-La-La-Lifetime). Cheesy Christmas movies are just the absolute best.
These cupcakes look (your pictures are gorgeous per usual) and sound amazing!
YA! Glad I am not alone! Thanks Jenna!
What an amazing way to go! Yum!
Thanks!
You are insane. These photos are gorgeous! And I too am a HP fan (in fact, I may or may not have an account with pottermore). So these cupcakes are right up my alley! So so so excited to try!
Thanks so much!
I am so up there with you on the HP obsession – always was and always will be a fan. These cupcakes are out of this world crazy! Love everything about them! Pinning!
Thanks Kathy! Have a great weekend!
Butterbeer!! I’m a huge HP fan too (totally stood in line waiting to get the ones that came out, not gonna lie), these are so fun and whimsical!
YEAHH! So excited you are a HP fan too! 🙂
Thanks Laura and have a great weekend!
Wow These look great i love harry potter although I am a bit of a closet fan as family are not really into it lol can’t wait to try them as i also love pretzels x x
Thanks Aimee! Have a great weekend!
What. The heck. These are sinful. Gorgeous photography, per usual!
THANK YOU! Have a great weekend, Sarah!
These are so freaking amazing!!! I love Harry Potter everything and those broom cookies? So adorable! Pinned!
Thank you so much! Have a great weekend! 🙂
ummmm yeah wow, I neeeed to make these like now!
Thanks Sophia! Have a great weekend!
I own all of the HP movies (and the books and the audiobooks) but for some reason every marathon that ABC Family runs still sucks me in. EVERY ONE OF THEM. This cupcakes. Here’s me wishing they had existed back before the eighth movie came out and we celebrated with an HP movie and food inspired evening. I would have made them in a heart beat. Speaking of, when’s the next marathon, ABC Family? I gotta make sure I’ve got these ingredients ready to go. 🙂 Amazing creativity and execution, Tieghan!
ME TOO! I do not know what it is about that marathon, but it always gets me! HA!
Thanks Julie and have a great weekend! Oh and I have no idea when the next HP weekend is. I looked on ABC family and didn’t see it on the line up.
GIRL this is insane. There’s something about the word “treacle” that makes me feel like I need to eat this immediately. I was a little disappointed when my brother when to Harry Potter World and informed me that butterbeer did not, in fact, contain any beer at all…BUT butterscotch and butter extract probably make up for that…and chocolate and pretzels and cupcakes 🙂
Also I’ve read all of the Harry Potter books twice. Eep.
I know, the world treacle is the best. It’s just fun to say!! 🙂
Also, the beer. UGh. I know it’s not typical, but we never drink pop, so beer it was! Thank you so much, Katie!! Have a great weekend!
You did not! Omg! I can’t even tell you how much I love these. I had no idea that you were a Potter fan too. I’ve read all of the books at least 3 times. Oh, and I would so love to have a 25 days of Christmas movie marathon with you! In my house the Christmas marathons start before Thanksgiving so I totally understand.
THANK YOU! And um the Christmas movies start before Thanksgiving here too. I mean, they have too! 🙂
This looks all amazing girl and your mom was right – these pics are gorgeous and sometimes its nice to see not so perfect things!! Yummy!
Thank you so much!! Have a great weekend!
Well done! love the creativity!
Thank you! Have a great weekend!
I love Harry Potter too! These cupcakes look incredible, love the treacle frosting!
Thanks Laura! Have a great weekend!
all of this – caramel and chocolate and cake and pretzels and these pictures and the frosting! LOVE!
Thank you!
Being a teacher–my friends and I would stay up to midnight to get new HP book then read it till dawn or later.
My school allows birthday and party treats for now but it is really hard to say NO to all those treats.
Hallmark starts showing their Christmas movies on OCTOBER 31 !
By the way those cupcakes look great and I would not say no to one–LOL.
Haha! That is awesome!! 🙂
Thanks Nancy and have a great weekend! PS I totally have christmas movies ready to be tapped! LOL!
These. Look. UH-MAZING!
I was such a huge HP book fan! I would reach each of them in one sitting, not stopping to eat or sleep, haha. I also totally went to the midnight book release parties.
I love the movies, too. But, the books are so much better 😛
Thanks Rachel!! I love the books, but also the movies too!
Fellow HP fan here! Definitely cried at the end of the last book because it was over.
Oh, and these cupcakes? SO EPIC.
Haha! I think I did too. I so did not want it to be over. 🙁
Thanks Steph and have a great weekend!
I think you may be my favorite Muggle EVER. Seriously, we probably have kindred Patronuses or something–love these cupcakes to no end! They put my Unofficial Harry Potter Cookbook to shame, and I love the idea of using treacle on these. I’m still waiting for the day when I can make some knickerbocker glory with plenty of ice cream on top 😉 Thanks for brightening my day, I’m rereading the series right now for the first time in about 7 years and we’re just entering the Triwizard Tournament. Cheers!
AWE!! Thank you!! I am watching the movies as I type! 🙂
You did HP series proud with these cupcakes!! So delicious!!
THANK YOU! 🙂
These look beyond amazing! My daughter who is finally getting into Harry Potter (she’s 8) would lose her little mind if I made them for Halloween.
Thanks Lucy! Hope you get a chance to make and you all love them! 🙂
I always love your photographs, and these are no exception–the extra props make them really fun. I had never heard of treacle butter before, and now I’m totally intrigued.
Thank you so much, Becky! Treacle butter is delicious!
So, my kids love Harry Potter, but I just could never get into it. However, these cupcakes look fabulous! (Did somebody say butterbeer?) And the broomstick cookies are adorable!
Thank you so much, Andrea! These are a kids cupcake for sure…but I mean, delicious for anyone of course! 🙂
Seriously! Your stuff always amazes me. And your photography! I have to say you are one of my favorite bloggers to idolize 🙂
OMG, really??!!! Thank you so much! 🙂
Hope you are having a great weekend!
Harry Potter for life! I just reread all the books for the first time since reading them as they came out. Yes been a while. I would have loved to have some of these around for that but I can just do a movie marathon with them instead O:-)
Thanks so much, Erin! And yes, Harry Potter for life! 🙂
Girl, you never cease to amaze me with your creativity. Words cannot describe how badly I am craving one of these butterbeer cupcakes to devour right now. WOW they are incredible!
THANK YOU! You are so sweet and your soup? I am still thinking about it! 🙂
And NOW I want to re-read Harry Potter. Oh how I wish jordan would be interested in the books! I’d totally make her these cupcakes if it would make her read them!
I know, I know!! I am watching the first movie as I type! 🙂
I noticed that this recipe was awfully similar to Pastry Affair’s recipe http://www.pastryaffair.com/blog/2011/7/14/butterbeer-cupcakes.html…
I developed the cupcake recipe on my own with a few ingredients pulled from her recipe, yes. I also cited my sources below in the notes to give her credit.
Two questions- where do you find a vanilla bean to harvest? And can the vanilla bean and unsulphered molasses be replaced with other ingredients?
Hey Allie, the vanilla beans can be bought at the grocery store or here on amazon. The molasses is pretty important in developing the flavor, but if you must you can use honey or maple syrup.
Oh and the vanilla beans can be left out completely.
Hope you love these!
Yum, I have to make this fall. Looks delicious!
Thanks!
Thanks so much for posting these! I just finished making a batch…and I’m definitely not a baker but wow, they were awesome. Best butterbeer cupcakes I’ve made/tried yet!
YES!! So excited you are loving these! Thanks Brittany!
I just made these for a party and even though it’s years after you posted the recipe, I wanted to let you know I was so impressed with its accuracy and flavor. It made EXACTLY 18 cupcakes and the frosting was EXACTLY the perfect amount for that many cupcakes and the 9 oz of chocolate chips were the PERFECT weight to cover 40 pretzels. 22 minutes was the exact baking time the cupcakes needed, and they were perfectly round on top, moist, fluffy, and not excessively sugary. I really have never baked anything that was so flawlessly proportioned. Bravo! Also, of course, they were delicious and beautiful and oh-so-buttery and butterscotchy. Everyone who ate them was awed. The only minor thing I would’ve changed was cutting down the baking soda to 1/2 a teaspoon maybe. 1 t seemed like a bit much and I could detect an ever-so-faint hint of it in the finished cupcakes. I’m a little hyper-sensitive to baking soda, though, so it was probably just me. 🙂 Thanks so much for sharing this awesome recipe!
Thank you so much Claire!! I am so happy these turned out awesome for you!
Thank you for an awesome recipe. Just made these and OMG. ???
So happy you loved these!! Thanks so much Jacqui!
We are big Harry Potter fans here too. Friday nights, me & the kids have a movie night & make a special dessert. Last night was Prisoner of Azkaban & these special Harry Potter inspired cupcakes…. Well…. WOW!!! These are amazing! They were perfect, flavors & presentation. Truly magical cupcakes!
Thank you for the great recipe.
WOW! Sounds so awesome! So jealous.
So happy you guys got to enjoy these while watching (:
Hey just made these – really great. I did use the toffee in the batter – made them look awesome when cut into. Chopped up the additional pretzels and instead of mixing them into the frosting, I sprinkled them over the piped frosting.
Few tips – I would make the butterbeer sauce first – depending on how warm your kitchen is it might need extra time to thicken up a bit before drizzling. Extra pretzel bits seem necessary given how sweet the cupcakes and frosting turned out- however you decide to incorporate them – that salt and crunch are awesome!
Next time I might also use less whipping cream in the frosting – it was very soft and already very sweet so I kept pausing and putting it in the fridge – came out too soft to hold up pretzels long end-up?
Great recipe – thanks!
Hey Kelly! So happy you love the cupcakes. yeah! Thanks so much for the helpful tips for readers! 🙂
Hey Tieghan, do you think this recipe could be used for a full-size cake too? I’ve got a birthday coming up. 🙂
I think this would be great as a full size cake! It will make a 2 layer cake. Let me know if you have questions. Hope you love the cake! 🙂 And happy early birthday!
can you just buy chocolate covered pretzels? Hershey’s makes some that are DELISH!!
Hi Pam! I think that will work fine with this recipe! I hope you love this!
I made these today with my daughter and we both agree that the frosting is delicious. The chocolate covered pretzels and butterscotch ganache were also a nice touch. The cake, however, was a miss. We baked it for 20 minutes, they were baked through fine but there was just something missing to give them the extra wow factor. We even included the toffee chips.
Hi Ashley! I am so glad you and your daughter loved the pretzels and frosting. I am sorry about the cake though.. Are there any questions I could help you with? xTieghan
My friend is allergic to cocoa so I wasn’t going to do the chocolate covered pretzels but I just saw there is cocoa in the frosting. Would it be okay to just eliminate the cocoa powder from the frostin?
Hi Gabby! Yes you could eliminate the cocoa and just make it a buttercream frosting. Enjoy!
These look amazing! I want to try out the recipe but do you think I could replace the vanilla bean with vanilla extract??
Hey Sarah,
That would work, I would do 1 teaspoon of vanilla extract. I hope you love the recipe, please let me know if you have any other questions! xTieghan